Ratcliffe Trial Day 15 – Jury says Guilty

Tagged as: climate_action environmentalism ratcliffe repression
Neighbourhoods: nottingham ratcliffe

14 December 2010

All 20 defendants are found guilty of Conspiracy to Commit Aggravated Trespass at Ratcliffe-on-Soar Power Station in April 2009.


They are required to come back to court at 12noon on Friday for sentencing.

All in Nottingham Crown Court again at 10am Tuesday.  After His Honour Judge Teare made his directions, the jury were first sent out on Friday.  They came back to court a couple of times to ask questions. After the weekend, they came back yesterday [Monday] to continue their deliberations.  Again a couple more questions, but it was becoming clear that they were quite divided. At 3.40pm yesterday, they were looking a bit tired and sent a note to the Judge, asking if they could go home for the day. They had been considering their verdict for 10 hours up to then. The Judge then told them that when they came back today ... he would accept a majority verdict.

Today [Tuesday], they retired again at 10.13am.  At 11.10am they returned after a total of 11.07hours.

The clerk read out the indictment:

20x names. are charged as follows, That they:

Conspired to Commit Aggravated Trespass, Contrary to section 1(1) of the Criminal Law Act 1977.

Verdict - GUILTY. [for all the defendants]

Strangely, the verdict was unanimous, when you consider that the judge had said he would accept a majority after their earlier difficulty in reaching a decision.

The Judge said that he was not going to hand down prison sentences now.  However, after hearing of some that had previous convictions he said he may be considering suspended sentences for those. Others were of previous 'good character' might be receiving community punishment order, to do unpaid work. He went on, that this trial had cost the country a vast amount of money.  As their actions have been found to have been unnecessary, then I don't see why they can't contribute, he said.

All are required to return to court at 12noon on Friday 17th December.

Personally. I don't think that their case could have been better expressed.  Having sat through the whole case, I was privileged in hearing the expert evidence that was of some substance and alarming. After all that exposure to the facts, then if the jury can't see that urgency of a need for action, then I am of course pessimistic in how on earth we are going to convince the wider public of the need for action.

Perhaps we are all doomed :-(

I have added my best wishes to all the defendants throughout the progress of this case. As it turns out ... fuck all use my good wishes were. I am sad for the defendants in loosing and being found guilty, but I am also sad for my own health and everybody else’s. If people are deterred from taking more direct action on these issues, nothing else substantial is going on.  As the recent events at the Cancún climate summit in Mexico have clearly demonstrated, if we leave it up to companies and politicians to act, then we will be waiting a very long time. Certainly past the tipping points we heard so much about. Beyond which we might not be able to do very much about our demise.

Will the last one alive on the planet, kindly turn the lights out!

Statement from the Defendants

Press Release

Ratcliffe on Trial Blog


Indymedia daily coverage of the progress of this trial:

Ratcliffe Trial: Nottingham Crown Court November 2010

2009 Nottingham Mass Arrest of 114 Climate Activists in Raid in Nottingham

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Conspiracy Trial Begins [Feature]

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe conspiracy to trespass trial opens today

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 2 - Prosecution’s Opening 

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 3 - Prosecution case continues

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial: Prosecution Opens [Feature 2]

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 4 - Prosecution case concludes

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 5 – Defence case opens

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 6 – The Defence Continues

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 7  ‘Snowed off’

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 8 – Defence Calls MP's

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 9 – Defence Calls More Experts

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 10 – Defence Calls more Defendants

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 11 - Defence Concludes its Case

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 12 – Concluding Speeches

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 13 – Final bits & Jury Retires 

2010 Nottingham Activist Speech On The Ratcliffe Trials

2010 Nottingham Ratcliffe Trial Day 14 – Jury Still Retired

Photographer - Media: One Eye on the Road. Nottingham.  UK
Email:                 tash@indymedia.org
Web:                   http://digitaljournalist.eu
Member of the National Union of Journalists [NUJ]
"It is not enough to curse the darkness.
                                   It is also necessary to light a lamp!!"

Email Contact email: tash@indymedia.org



Cheers for all your reports and I'm sorry about the result.

Love and solidarity

Very disappointed to hear the outcome but a big thanks for the serious commitmment of all the defendants, and all those who had to suffer the anguish of waiting months to hear if they would be prosecuted.

Also a big thanks to Tash for attending court each day and delivering such prompt reports. Contrast this with the BBC who could not be bothered to send a reported on the 5 min walk from their studios to report on such a significant trial in terms of environmental and criminal justice issues. Seems the BBC can only repost press releases these day!

There is more to be said but perhaps we should hold off so as not to jeopardise any appeal.